We’re Cooking: Toasted Irish Cheddar Sandwich with Portobello and Tomato

It is almost embarrassing to say that my favorite meal that we had in Ireland was essentially a grilled cheese sandwich…but a good grilled cheese sandwich is nothing to snub, and this one came from a farm to table restaurant housed within one of the oldest farmers markets in the world, the Farmgate Cafe inside the English Market in Cork.  Made with great aged white Irish cheddar and loads of local farm to table tomatoes and mushrooms, grilled just perfectly with good Irish buttered bread with a side of sweet and sour cucumbers.

The Farmgate Cafe

And, super easy to make….


Toasted Irish Cheddar Sandwich with Portobello Mushrooms and Tomatoes
2 sliced good white bread – Texas toast would be perfect here
2 oz aged white Irish cheddar
1 large vine ripe tomato – sliced thin
1 large Portobello mushroom – grilled until soft with a bit of olive oil
1 1/2 tablespoons butter
Black pepper

Butter one side of each slice of bread with 1 tablespoon butter.  Preheat a 10 inch skillet.  Slice the cheese into thin strips and layer on the bottom of both sides of the bread. Layer the tomatoes on top of one piece of the bread and cheese then add the mushrooms and a good dash of black pepper.  Top with the other slice of bread.  Add the 1/2 tablespoon of butter to the pan and grill until nicely toasted on each side, about 2 minutes on each side. Cut in half and serve.

3 Comments on “We’re Cooking: Toasted Irish Cheddar Sandwich with Portobello and Tomato

  1. There is just something about grilled cheese, and clearly it’s an international thing.


  2. Pingback: We’re Exploring: Ireland…Part 2….The First Few Days of Driving on the Wrong Side of the Road « Dallas Uncorked: Red Wine with Breakfast

Red Wine with Breakfast

Every Glass Is An Adventure


Sommelier, Personal Chef & Concierge Creating Elegant Dinner Parties and Unique Wine Tasting Events to the Big Island of Hawaii

Cogill Wine & Film

Cogill WIne & Film and Cogill Consulting brings together the talents of Producer Gary Cogill and his wife, Sommelier Hayley Hamilton Cogill, working together, yet thriving individually, for a perfect pairing of wine and film.

%d bloggers like this: